BETULKAH FAKTA YANG DIPEROLEHI DI SEBUAH BLOG?
by Rahmat Haroun on Friday, February 18, 2011 at 9:33pm
HE Ambassador Dr Fakhreddin Mukti is a dear personal friend of mine. I had dinner with him in Mohandessin Cairo before the Midan Tahrir revolution and he was the one that reiterated to me that of the 'Tahfiz ' school students in Malaysia that en...tered Al-Azhar university and its sister institutions in the Classical Islamic studies, 50% flunk outright, of the 50% that passed 45% took more than the normal 3 1/2 years to get a BA and 5% could articulate and formulate their thoughts in arabic.
Meaning 95% are estranged from thinking and formulating their thoughts in the arabic language, which is the medium of university studies instruction. This after a whole primary + secondary education in Malaysia with arabic and Quranic studies as the main stream, including a 5 year long stint of 'memorising' The Quran.
In the end to be beaten by European and Central Asian and African students in the private American University in Cairo, where 100% of the students could articulate and formulate their thoughts in arabic after SIX months of rigorous classes.
The estrangement of the malay students from the language that they are supposed to be at default with, is best seen like how they ran from the Midan Tahrir revolution, like runneth the proverbial yellow donkeys in the Quran. Our malay students simply cannot immerse in anything other than their own comfort zone, miserable though that may be.
---> Kamariah Haroon: if this is true, JAKIM has to do something to assess the sekolah agama and the sekolah ma'ahad system of educatiion. but how come our ulama who graduated from mesir are very well versed in their mission of dakwah and very well-versed in arabics. is it because they went through a different system of education before? as i know,most of them went to sekolah agama rakyat or sekolah pondok.
----> Rahmat Haroun Penulis seorang teknokrat Malysia yanghidup lama di Kaherah, Mesir.
----> Kamariah Haroon is he talking about the present students? or does it include our present ulama who graduated from mesir? the fact is quite contradictory to the actual performance of our present ulama. i've been following so many lessons of different disciplines of islamic studies from ulama graduated from mesir, i find no fault in their arabics. if he's talking of present students, then JAKIM and kemeterian pengajian tinggi must do something about this calamity
----->Rahmat Haroun Present.
------>Kamariah Haroon kalau present students, memang x begitu mengejutkan sebab depa semua kena spoon-fed. bukan siswa university pengajian islam saja begitu, siswa university aliran melayu/english pun mcm tu . pelajar2 sekolah pondok terpaksa cari ilmu sendiri bukan di spoon fed oleh guru2 mereka.
----->Fadhli Rahim Mungkin betul, cuba tgk video ni ye. Pandangan hamba Allah mesir tentang pelajar melayu di Mesir http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sqhX_SlAzNs&feature=player_detailpage#t=77s
----> Fadhli Rahim
Dari sudut pandangan ustadz dari mesir tu, sebahagian pelajar kita tak berapa fasih berbahasa Arab. Susah nak baca buku-buku bahasa Arab. Sehingga dia belajar bahasa semata2 nak tolong student2 kat sana.
Kalau tgk lagi video tu, dia kata 6 bulan pertama, dia hafal 10 perkataan satu hari. 6 bulan kemudian, belajar guna perkataaan-perkataan yang dia hafal. Dia dah ada struktur belajar bahasa baru. Agaknya banyak bergaul dengan orang2 kelantan, dah 10 tahun dia kecek doh.
No comments:
Post a Comment